“What was once a matter of practicality—you dress your baby in white dresses and diapers; white cotton can be bleached—became a matter of ‘Oh my God, if I dress my baby in the wrong thing, they’ll grow up perverted,’ ”
In a recent Smithsonian.com article, “When Did Girls Start Wearing Pink?” Jeanne Maglaty delves into the baby obsession of gender identification through clothing. We know the rule right? Girls wear pink, boys wear blue and it is only fair to the world to dress your child appropriately so there are no awkward introductions or osmosis of baby gender confusion.
So let’s all take a moment to point and laugh at the picture above, featuring Franklin Roosevelt dressed like a girl!!! Oh my god, look at those shiny buckle shoes and white flowy dress!!! What about that feathery hat, too? Don’t even get me started on his long, girly hair! FDR sure did grow up perverted didn’t he? Growing up to be the only American President to be elected for more than two terms, instating the New Deal– one of the most radical and innovative relief programs for a severely depressed economy. Man, what a jerk. The U.S.A. definitely would have been better off if he was photographed with a gun, in a cowboy hat. Like a real American– no matter that this photo was taken way before the image of the rustic American cowboy became popular.
What I am fascinated with is the immense desire to fortuitously attribute gender to infants, as if a color or a headband is a predictor of a future marriage to someone of the opposite sex (as if that is the only option), and a 6-figure salary. How cultures deem masculine or feminine is completely inconsistent, even within U.S. cultural history. Gendering our babies through consumerist acts boil down to a popularity contest. Maglaty, tells us that “today’s color dictate wasn’t established until the 1940s, as a result of Americans’ preferences as interpreted by manufacturers and retailers.” Pink for girls and blue for boys was established as a social norm within the last 70 years. That is not a long time ago! This color preference also has to coincide with the major popularization of the department store, like Sears, Robuck and Co. and Macys.
So to say blue is for boys and pink is for girls is very typical, American capitalist tradition of consumption. Here, we’re not only talking about fashion, we’re talking about giving business ventures access into every aspect of our lives, dictating how we respond to our children, letting companies, whose sole purpose is to advertise, to manipulate public perception to buy, buy, buy tell us what is wrong and right, what is a good child, and what is a perverted child. This is a socialization of our future taxpayers to believe that advertisement is truth, and conformity is obligatory. To hold our children up to the expectation of a pink or blue poster advertisement is wrong and unfair to the individuality of an unique human.


Check out this article about the controversy that has flared up over a J. Crew ad featuring a mother putting pink nail polish on her son:
http://www.chicagotribune.com/business/ct-talk-pink-toenails-0414-20110413,0,4227519.story
A Fox News shrink and columnist was PISSED about this and said that “This is a dramatic example of the way that our culture is being encouraged to abandon all trappings of gender identity” and then a conservative research think tank called it “blatant propaganda celebrating transgendered children.”
So keep in mind, folks:
DON’T USE PINK NAIL POLISH ON A BOY OR SOCIETY AS WE KNOW IT WILL FALL APART.
Hey Sheila! Great site and great photo of FDR…however, I disagree with your argument.
You discredit people who think that if they dress their baby in the wrong color they’ll grow up perverted, and rightly so. Children that young will never remember what color clothes they wore and the impact on their development will be nil.
However, you later use the same logic that you discredited earlier, when you imply that dressing babies in the culturally dictated colors will teach the babies that “conformity is obligatory”. No it won’t, for the same reason that dressing a boy in pink won’t make him a pervert — babies won’t remember that.
You further claim that it is “unfair to the individuality of a unique human” to dress them in gendered colors. However, babies and young toddlers frankly aren’t yet developed enough to make decisions about what to wear, so by that logic dressing them in ANYTHING would be unfair to their individuality (not to mention that they haven’t yet developed unique skills, interests, and personality traits that make people individuals).
As babies grow into children and later into young adults they should be encouraged to display their individuality as they develop into a unique individual.
To me dressing your baby in gendered colors is simply a tool so that strangers can know the appropriate gender pronoun when talking about how cute your baby is! I think this is a useful tool; we’ve all had that awkward moment asking a new parent of a baby dressed in pale yellow, “How old is…..it?”
Hi Jordan! Thanks for your contribution to the diversity of voices on our blog! We appreciate your time to think critically about our posts and to share your thoughts on them as well! I would like to take a few moments to respond to what you have said.
I would first like to question the initial desire of someone wanting to know the “gender” of a child when that child has not yet been able to decide for him/herself. What is so significant about knowing if the child is a boy or girl when really, what we marvel at when we see a recent-born child is the fact that, not that long ago, a beautiful creation happened. The main concern of the blog post “When Brothers and Sisters Shared Clothes” is not whether children will remember the clothes they wore, but the socialization process of parents or influential governors over children. The problem is not that boys wear blue clothes or that girls wear pink clothes– the problem is that through years of advertisements and culturally conceived “norms” of men and women, blue equals boy and pink equals girl. This is an injustice for the creativity and exploration of the self that some people may not want to conform too. The easy answer would be to say, “express yourself however you want, don’t listen to what other people say,” but through so many reports and statistics and interviews from the experiences of real people, we know that just “expressing yourself” isn’t always possible or easy. We can take our cues from conservative extremists from Fox news in a response to J Crew’s ad (which by the way, way to go J Crew!) Colors are not gender determinants, even our body and sex parts are not always gender determinants.
One goal of So To Speak is to break and subvert traditional gender roles in whatever shape and size they hold. After, we believe that in reconstructing de-masculinized and de-feminized gender qualities people will notice the importance of including all types of voices and styles into popular discourse and, therefore, reinforce equality between different life choices of all members of society.