Hey look! A statue of a woman! Oh wait, no.

I read an article in the Post’s “Arts” section today that absolutely fascinated me. It’s about the disparity between statues of men and statues of women in the United States. I’m going to try my best not to just paraphrase the entire article, since you can read it for yourself, but I do want to point out several interesting points in it and try to respond to those with questions of my own.

So.  The problem is that of the 5,193 public sculptures in the United States, only 394 are women.  That’s 4,799 men and 394 women.  Yes, you’re right.  That sucks.    (P.S.  Of those 394 women, a lot are just abstract representations of concepts like “Freedom” and “North America” given an anonymous female form.  So, BOOBS but no face or identity).

The article explores a lot of fascinating explanations for this trend, which I will comment on BELOW and which I will then immediately inscribe on a commemorative statue.  (Which will get that number up to 395!  Yeah!)

Explanation One: We don’t have as many statues of women because our country’s history has been male-dominated (no kidding) and therefore all the heroes have been men, and that’s too bad but it’s just the way it is. If statues = heroic figures and heroic figures = men, then statues = men.

Hm.  Sounds like a chicken-egg problem to me.  Because couldn’t I then ask, “If there were more statues of heroic women around for little American girls to see, maybe then those little girls grow up feeling empowered and then do more heroic things in turn?”  Also, America, just put up more damn statues.  I guarantee you can find enough awesome historical women to honor.  Really.

ALSO, it’s kind of delightful that we can use STATUES as a litmus test for how male-dominated our country’s history has been.  If you think of this statue disparity as a REFLECTION of gender equality problems in our country, and not as much of a problem IN ITSELF (nobody is getting directly underpaid or abused or losing rights because of it), then things seem really interesting.

Explanation Two: Statues are just kind of a “dude” thing. They’ve traditionally been all about depicting military men doing heroic things in male poses, and that tradition is hard to buck. The problem may be cyclical in that people think of statues this way, and therefore just don’t think about making statues of women.

I personally may be guilty of this mindset. I mean, I love the National Mall, and absolutely respect the sacrifices of everyone who is memorialized on it.  But essentially, the two most popular (and largest) statues on the strip itself are of an over-sized, wise-looking, God-like man staring out at a gigantic white phallus.  Again, I don’t mean disrespect here. I just mean that, yeah, our country is kind of “male” in that sense of military bravado and honoring that military bravado.  So this explanation just kind of makes me chuckle and nod.  If it makes you angry, comment!

Explanation Three: Women just aren’t making enough fuss about this. Throughout history, women haven’t been the biggest advocates for statues of themselves. Notre Dame professor Erika Doss asks, “Are women just being deferential to a male-dominated history?”

Part of me feels insulted by this quote, because there are so many women right now trying to fight unfair representations and are anything but “deferential” to this kind of problem (including the women mentioned at the very beginning of the article trying to get a statue of Harriet Tubman up in Congress). But then another part of me recognizes that Doss is right– not all women care about “less urgent” women’s issues like these, and not all (maybe not even many) even realize that this statue problem exists. I mean, I know that I personally didn’t know it was until reading this article, or at least hadn’t given much thought to the cultural significance of statues.  But then you run into the whole unfair portrayal of “Oh man, those women are whining again, and this time it’s about STATUES.  I mean, really, when will these feminists realize things are equal now and then can just shut up?”  This is an anti-feminist reaction that makes me very sad both in its misguidedness and its pervasiveness.  But I could write a whole other post about that.

Explanation Four: Women have better priorities about this statue business. Several scholars and activists in the article suggest that another possible reason for the disparity is that instead of focusing on putting up statues of themselves, women prefer to keep working for actual change. For example, female union activists decided not to put up a memorial after the Triangle Shirtwaist Factory Fire 100 years ago, which killed 146 mainly female workers, but INSTEAD to memorialize those women by putting funds and efforts into making fair work environments.

So does this make women nobler, selfless? Or, as Doss suggests, are we just being too passive in, throughout history, not demanding more statuary? While part of me agrees that money should be put toward, for example, more contraceptive programs instead of toward building a statue of revolutionary birth control advocate Margaret Sanger, the other part of me keeps hearing, over and over, a quote from early in the article, from a Washington area psychologist and founder of an equality nonprofit:

“[The statue discrepancy] sends a very clear nonverbal message about the relative stature of boys and girls and men and women. It expands the broader message that the contributions of women don’t matter…Humans tend to trust the nonverbal, and the statues send a very clear nonverbal message. Girls can’t be what they can’t see.”

Wow.  So that goes back to the chicken-egg problem.  In order to maintain and increase equality, we have to sometimes start at the bottom and move upward.  That means making sure our country is filled with positive portrayals of strong women– in the media, in advertising, and, yes, in statuary.

But how do we go about this?  It’s not something that can be fixed by passing a law.  It’s a cultural thing.  And, besides raising awareness, being vocal, and teaching these values to our next generation of women, I’m not sure I have an answer on how something like this statue issue– something rooted in a CULTURAL or social problem and not in something “concretely” and therefore obviously unfair (such as political rights discrepancies, equal pay, etc.) can be “fixed.”

Any ideas?

1 thought on “Hey look! A statue of a woman! Oh wait, no.”

Leave a Comment