Pilar Albarracin and Shehrazade

My professor Jen Atkinson recently emailed me about Pilar Albarracin, a Spanish artist who works with photography, installations and performances, among other media, and whose focus is feminist issues. Albarracin’s work examines Spanish and Andalusian folklore, popular traditions and cultural rituals. The project of Albarracin’s work exposes patriarchal narratives that subjugate women in everyday or ordinary situations. Rosa Martinez says about Albarracin’s work, “[h]er productions have focused on the analysis of dominant narratives and, specifically, on the clichés which represent Andalusian identity; not from a remote and intellectualised perspective, but through an emotional and subversive immersion in the anthropology of the everyday”.

In La Noche 1002, Albarracin portrays a woman belly dancing, whose outfit changes from golden sequins and jewels into chains. Martinez describes it as “a fascinating visual fusion [which] converts the tinkling eroticism of a belly dance into the jangling sounds of the chains of oppression”. In La Noche 1002 I, a photograph shows a woman bound with rope on the roof of a car next to some baggage. Inside the car, a Moroccan immigrant man is sitting in the driver’s seat.

Shehrazade has been referenced and recycled in multiple feminist literary and artistic projects. Interpretations and reconstructions of the story and the character’s significance have ranged from labeling Shehrazade as an empowered character to a victimised one, with explanations making that spectrum of understanding plausible. For me, what is interesting about Albarracin’s project is how the significance of 1001 nights could work towards a tragic-comic effect. I think this is what Martinez refers to when she says,  “Albarracín’s world is full of parodies and tragi-comedies that verge on cathartic paroxysm”. For, if Sherazade is to be perceived as empowered in her manipulation of Shehrayar, and to have to suffer this fate on being reduced to a commodity on top of a car on the 1002th night, the effect is tragi-comic. This seems to speak to an irony about a decrease in women’s agency and place in society since Shehrazade’s time (although fictional). . Alternately, if Shehrazade’s performance in story-telling makes her a victim of Shehrayar’s power, then Albarracin’s statement becomes more of a witness of the tragic continuity of the lack of improvement in women’s place in a patriarchal society. Both interpretations of the context, when superimposed on the work, imply the continuity of a subjugated identity, and either way, I think that Albarracin’s work wants to exist in that tension of the tragic and comic. That tension  speaks of the nature of her work as it explores reality becoming a representation, then distorts the representation within the context of tradition, folklore and history.

What is striking to me about this project, however, is not the portrayal of the “oppression” of the Arab woman. The portrayal of an Arab woman as imprisoned and as a piece of baggage is an already established sensationalistic stereotype within Western feminist discourses. It is rather the fact that the belly dance performance could possibly be a juxtaposition of the history of the Arab woman’s Orientalist stereotype as “hyper-sexual” with the current stereotype of “oppressed”. The car photograph, however, does not attempt to include that history in its portrayal. Although visually striking,  it remains uni dimensional in its feminist representation, and it does not necessarily offer a political message that transcends the witness of patriarchy and dehumanisation.

The question that personally troubles me whenever I encounter feminist representations of women of other cultures, especially Arab,  is whether in commenting on gender roles and/or the construction of female identities, the artist or writer in question is furthering an unproductive and limiting stereotype of oppression, or is working towards a representation that is feminist, but fully aware of the political, cultural and historical implications of its representation. I think Albarracin’s work is visually beautiful and striking, yet as far as its feminist message goes, its sincerity, or irony, still remains ambiguous to me. I think it is aware of the history, but might not be attempting to represent it alongside the feminist project in every single piece.

2 thoughts on “Pilar Albarracin and Shehrazade”

  1. Siwar–

    How would your interpretations of Albarracin’s work be affected if he was Arab and not Spanish?

    What I mean is, might the ambiguity in your feelings about her work be rooted in the fact that she is a Western woman commenting on Arab women? (You might already be saying that in your second to last paragraph).

    Reply
  2. Alyse,
    thanks for your comment! What you said is SO true (to a certain extent), which is my hesitance (sometimes) about accepting Western commentary on Arab identity. The interesting thing, however, is that Albarracin strongly identifies with *her* Andalusian roots, which might (potentially) bring her closer to a realm of Arab feminism, or maybe a feminism informed of the history of the construct of an Arab identity by non-Arab intellectuals. Yet, it is the notion of the inclusion of that history, which is found in her belly dancing performance but not the car image, that I see as necessary to a representation (or its challenging), especially since I feel it is truly more feminist to go beyond “witness”, so that exposing the subjugation of women is less likely to become an issue that is merely exploited politically in a larger picture. It is tricky, though, balancing that.

    Reply

Leave a Comment